Hello friend,

In the startup world, there’s no shortage of advice on finding product-market fit. But while founders often obsess over building a great product, the truth is, product innovation alone rarely guarantees success. There’s another, equally important piece of the puzzle: distribution. How you get your product into the hands of users can make or break your company.

This week, I want to dive into a concept that I believe is crucial for every founder to understand: the law of diminishing distribution arbitrage. It’s a principle that highlights why some startups explode onto the scene and why others, despite having a solid product, fail to gain traction.

The Distribution Advantage: More Than Just a Tactic

Let’s start by clarifying what a distribution advantage really means. At its core, a distribution advantage is any edge that allows your product to reach more users more effectively than your competitors. It’s not just about having a great marketing campaign or a clever referral program; it’s about creating a self-sustaining growth loop that’s tightly integrated with your product.

Think about it like this: in the early days of any market, distribution channels are wide open. Early movers can exploit these channels to capture market share rapidly. But over time, as more companies enter the space, these channels become crowded, and the effectiveness of any given distribution tactic diminishes. This is the law of diminishing distribution arbitrage.

Case Studies: Distribution Tactics That Worked—Until They Didn’t

Let’s take a walk down memory lane and look at some of the most iconic distribution strategies in the startup world:

1. Paypal’s Referral Hack: Paypal’s strategy was simple yet powerful—give users $10 for every person they referred. The kicker? The money appeared instantly in your Paypal account, and you could use it immediately. This immediacy was a game-changer, driving viral growth at a time when instant digital transactions were still a novelty.
2. Facebook’s University Rollout: Facebook didn’t start as a global social network. It began by targeting specific universities, creating an aura of exclusivity. This hyper-targeted approach made Facebook a must-have for students, who were eager to join the platform that their peers were raving about.
3. Zapier’s Long-Tail SEO: Zapier leveraged long-tail keywords to create SEO pages for every possible app integration. By doing so, they ensured that when someone searched for a specific integration, Zapier was the first result. This strategy drove massive organic traffic and helped establish Zapier as the go-to platform for app integrations.
4. Notion’s Community-Driven Templates: Notion built a community around its product by encouraging users to create and share templates. This not only drove engagement but also made it easier for new users to see the value of the product quickly.

Each of these tactics was groundbreaking at the time, but their effectiveness has waned over the years as the market caught up. Today, simply offering a referral bonus or creating SEO pages isn’t enough to guarantee success. The novelty that made these tactics work initially has worn off, and in many cases, they’ve been copied to death.

The Secret Behind Successful Distribution: Product-Driven Growth

So, what’s the common thread between these success stories? It’s not just that these companies had clever marketing tactics—they had clever marketing tactics that were deeply intertwined with their product innovations.

Paypal’s referral program worked because it was more than just a referral program—it was a demonstration of the product’s core value proposition: instant, digital payments. Similarly, Facebook’s university rollout wasn’t just a marketing strategy—it was a product decision that shaped the early identity of the platform.

This is why copying someone else’s distribution strategy rarely works. The most effective distribution tactics are the ones that are almost impossible to separate from the product itself. They emerge organically from the way users interact with the product, rather than being bolted on as an afterthought.

Why Distribution Shouldn’t Be an Afterthought

I’ve spoken to many founders who believe that distribution is something to worry about later, after they’ve nailed product-market fit. But this approach is dangerously shortsighted. In reality, your distribution strategy should be baked into your product from day one.

Consider Dropbox. One of the reasons Dropbox became so viral was because it made sharing files with non-users incredibly easy. All you had to do was share a link. In a world where most people were still using clunky FTP servers or email attachments to share files, this was revolutionary. And it wasn’t just a clever marketing ploy—it was a core part of the product experience.

The lesson here is that you can’t afford to separate your product strategy from your distribution strategy. The two should be developed in tandem, with each informing the other. By doing so, you increase the chances that your product will have a built-in distribution advantage that can drive sustainable growth.

The Diminishing Returns of Imitation

There’s a reason why second-time founders are often more focused on distribution than first-time founders. They’ve seen firsthand how quickly a successful tactic can be copied and commoditized. Once a distribution channel becomes crowded, it’s only a matter of time before the returns start to diminish.

This is why it’s so important to be constantly experimenting with new distribution channels and tactics. The goal is to find something that works before the rest of the market catches on—and then to move on to the next thing before your current strategy loses its edge.

For example, let’s take a look at influencer marketing. A few years ago, partnering with influencers was a novel way to reach new audiences. But today, the space is saturated, and consumers are becoming increasingly skeptical of influencer endorsements. The effectiveness of this tactic is waning, and savvy marketers are already looking for the next big thing.

The Future of Distribution: What’s Next?

So, what does the future hold for distribution? I believe that the next wave of successful startups will be the ones that find new, innovative ways to integrate their distribution strategy with their product experience.

One potential area of opportunity is the rise of AI and machine learning. As these technologies become more advanced, there will be new ways to personalize and automate the distribution of products. For example, imagine a SaaS tool that uses AI to predict which users are most likely to churn and automatically offers them a personalized discount or feature upgrade. This kind of targeted, automated distribution could be incredibly powerful.

Another area to watch is the growing trend towards community-driven growth. Companies like Notion and Figma have shown that building a strong, engaged community around your product can be a powerful distribution channel in its own right. As more and more companies adopt this approach, we’re likely to see new innovations in how communities are built and leveraged for growth.

Conclusion: Don’t Sleep on Distribution

In conclusion, if there’s one takeaway from this discussion, it’s this: don’t underestimate the importance of distribution. A great product is essential, but without a smart, integrated distribution strategy, your chances of success are slim.

The law of diminishing distribution arbitrage means that what works today won’t necessarily work tomorrow. The key is to be constantly experimenting, constantly iterating, and constantly looking for new ways to get your product in front of users.

And remember: the most effective distribution strategies are the ones that are impossible to separate from the product itself. They’re the strategies that emerge naturally from the way users interact with your product, and they’re the strategies that will give you a true, lasting distribution advantage.

So as you continue to build your startup, don’t just focus on product-market fit. Focus on distribution-market fit as well. Because in the end, it’s not just about building a great product—it’s about getting that product into the hands of as many users as possible. And that’s where the real magic happens.

‍